Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Securities Law

Is being hancuffed to railing by security considered held hostage? charged with petty theft n prior 666.?


I was being chased thru the mall by their security, they told me to stop, i said "am i under arrest?", their answer was "no, we are investigating something". I continued to walk away thru a major department store, told by security to stop or i would be hit, I was hit 2-3 times and continues to walk away, went out exit to 2nd floor parking structure. Was told not to run towards stairs or i would be pushed down, ran 2 flights down and pushed down on 3rd. Attempted to walk away and was told i was placed under citizens arrest by security. Was placed on stairs, got up to leave (handcuffs on), was grabbed, attempted to pull away and so was dragged to raining and cuffed to it. I said " release me, im not an animal and being held hostage" One of them said (after several mins) "i think you should take him off the railing", i attempted to leave again, and was blocked to do so. I was identified 10 mins later. I was handcuffed for about 1hr15mins more until officer got there n arrested me.

I in no way raised my hands, nor try to assault anyone, just walking.
No one in security witnessed any crime being committed, as stated, was held 10 mins before identified. I was not charged with resisting or assault by the police officers; The department store (where no crime was committed) does have the video tape of offficers trying to stop me from leaving the premises. Will the tape be easy to get, or should i get an attorney to do so?

And as for your comment ( americanfreeman) i guess you already met bubba, can you give any tips on how to defend myself in there? seeing as you want to be the funny guy) This is a forum for answer not jokes.

The first thing to understand is that private security guards have no special legal authority. They can not lawfully do anything that a normal citizen can't do. They can not legally force you to submit to a search, you do not have to answer their questions, etc.
They can, however, affect a citizen's arrest if they witness you committing a crime. This means that they can use necessary force to detain you until the police arrive. They can also use necessary force to defend themselves from your attack, or defend another person from your attack, but like anyone else they still have a duty to retreat.
The guard was legally within his rights to handcuff you to the railing and detain you until the police arrived. It doesn't matter that it took the police over an hour to arrive.
The part where you were hit is a little more questionable. They would argue, of course, that this amount of force was necessary to detain you. You were, after all, fleeing from the scene of a crime and had disobeyed a lawful command to stop. They were probably within their legal rights to do this, however, if the blows were excessive or were not necessary to detain you then it would be battery. If there were no witnesses to assert that it was a battery then your complaint would probably be disregarded.

Note to Tempting But No Thanks: You might want to look up "citizen's arrest" in your state's law. Every state has a process that allows for citizens arrest.
Security guards would be rather ineffective if they couldn't affect a citizen's arrest.
Guard: I saw you steal that shirt. Come along with me.
Suspect: Uhm, no thanks, I'll be leaving now.
Guard: Okay. Have a nice day.

UPDATE: Security does not need to witness the theft if they are informed by a store employee who did witness the theft. The security guard can affect a citizen's arrest by proxy for the store that is serving as the complainant. You are entitled to the video footage as part of the normal discovery process if you take your case to trial. It doesn't sound like the tape helps you though since it probably shows you fleeing from the security guards. This makes you look rather guilty. Even if they didn't catch you on tape stealing, they have a witness who is stating that you did. You don't mention if they found the stolen item in your possession or not. If they did, that is their case right there. If not, then their case will be very weak.
You wouldn't have been charged with resisting arrest because that only applies if you resist arrest from the police, not security guards. If you can afford an attorney, it's always a good idea to have one. If you can't afford one, they will provide you with one when your court proceedings begin.

no, it is a very good and safe way to constrain a criminal.

Don't do the crime if you can't do the time.

Just wait until Big Bubba gets you alone in prison.

aside from doing stupid sh!t that gets you in trouble at the mall... no, security cannot forcibly detain you, unless they are a police officer or you physically assaulted someone.

That sounds illegal to me..

Tags
  Telecommunications   Tax and Taxation Law   Tech Law   Sport Law   Social Security Law   Sexual Harassment   Securities Law   Real Estate Law   Real Property Law   Professional Responsibility   Probate Law   Products Liability
Related information
  • Can a security guard stop and search you?

    A security guard has no more and no less legal authority than any other private citizen. If you are witnessed committing an offense they may detain you and, yes, physically restrain you if you resi...

  • Is it illegal to give a fake social security number on checks?

    A check is a legal document: it is a contract. Yes-- if you get caught by bouncing a check that has to go to collection. However, you will not have a problem unless a check bounces. So, yes, i...

  • RE: 9/11Debunked:BushBrotherNever in Charge of WTC Security?

    Fellow truth seekers, don't slam me for saying this, but we must be careful to word this issue correctly to stay focused on the security COMPANY and it's links to the Bush family, not Mar...

  • I was arrested for shoplifting. Th security guard followed me all around the store with item i intended ti pur

    Get a lawyer quick! You have a righ to remain silent. Don't speak to the police at all until you talk to a lawyer. You story sounds very believable. Simply explain it to the lawyer and he will...

  • How could an American citizen not have a Social Security number?

    If you are born at home, home schooled and not held a job outside the family, you could not have a SSN. I believe some Amish and Mennonites do not have SSN's.

    ...
  • A woman sues airport security and police for 10 million for only takedown?

    Well, the beauty of American jurisprudence is that you can pretty much sue anybody for any reason, but there is no way this woman is gonna win. In this day and age the cops had to take her actions...

  • A woman security person at my work scans me a bit too close for my liking, then after she frisks!!?

    Yes you need to get information from HR in writing, explaining the policy and procedure of this security policy. If she is being overzealous in her duties, the procedure manual should make that fa...

  • Stolen Social Security card but?

    Just write a letter stating the facts truthfully. Have a friend or teacher who is good with English to go over it for you. Be sure to mail it certified, return receipt requested, so you will ha...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster