Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Personal Injury Law

You represent the Chicago Cubs. Based on these facts, which defense to negligence is likely most likely to def


Sandy attended the Chicago Cubs v. Chicago White Sox "Cross-Town Classic" last Saturday afternoon at Wrigley Field in Chicago. Regrettably, Sandy was hit in on the head by a foul ball as she stood in the stands, talking with her friend rather than watching the game. Sandy filed a lawsuit in the Cook County, Illinois state court alleging that the Chicago Cubs were negligent in causing her personal injuries, pain and suffering, lost wages, and medical bills. You represent the Chicago Cubs. Based on these facts, which defense to negligence is likely most likely to defend your client?
a the Cubs had no duty to protect Sandy
b the Cubs breached no duty to protect Sandy
c Sandy voluntarily assumed the risk of being hit by a foul ball
d Sandy was comparatively negligent because her conduct was unreasonable under the circumstances

a, b and c
The ball clubs warn fans to be aware of foul balls during games, it's mentioned in the programs, and also posted in signs around the ballpark.

c Sandy voluntarily assumed the risk of being hit by a foul ball

Anyone attending a baseball game has to be on watch for flying balls, bats and baseball players. There is a legal statement on your ticket when you buy it that says the team is not responsible for anyone hit by any of these objects. You assume a risk when entering a ballpark, you must keep your eyes open particularly for foul balls.

I would answer B

If you have ever read the fine print on a ticket, alarm bells would go off inside your head. The Cubs have a reasonable obligation to steer spectators, fans and personnel away from second hand smokin bats and balls.

Now think of the apartments across the street that protest the raising of nets that obscure their non paid view. ~Why~ these people are invitingly welcoming property damage and personal injury for love of the game.

I would go with C. But I would also do my own homework. You are probably violating a code of student conduct, especially if you are in law school.

Yep, definitely C.

Tags
  Real Estate Law   Real Property Law   Professional Responsibility   Probate Law   Products Liability   Personal Injury Law   Native American Law   Military Law   Medical Malpractice   Mediation   Legal Malpractice
Related information
  • Can we drop our PI lawyer? Will this be more trouble than it's worth?

    You could generate a few problems if you drop them without some proper preparation. First of all, your agreement with them may entitle them to a percentage of the settlement even if you fire t...

  • Question about aggravated assault and lawsuits?

    No, Bob can't "make money," he can only recover his damages. Since he will have to pay attorney fees, he will be a net loser even if he wins his lawsuit, so this would be a very s...

  • Pressing Charges Against Casino Hotel For Bug Bite?

    Would it be considered a personal injury or what? It would be considered absolutely ridiculous. That's what.

    ...
  • Under CA state bar rules, what are the proper steps for an attorney to withdraw from his client's case?

    There are only three ways: 1. The client fire's his/her attorney (in writing) and signs a substitution of attorney - civil, form. 2. The client hires new counsel and both attorney...

  • Personal Injury Lawsuit for sister?

    I would STRONGLY SUGGEST you have your sister contact a lawyer on something like this. The problem right now that I see is that UNLESS she already has a "legal agreement" on child su...

  • Personal Injury? Slander? Wrongful Termination?

    You have witnesses, and coworker has no proof. I'd be amazed if they terminate you. You may get a reprimand or warning put in your record. If so, tell them you object and want your protest...

  • The opposite lawyer in personal injury case have right to ask question about your relative in discovery exam?

    Singh Is Kinng, I'm sorry to hear about your situation. I was hurt once in Idaho when a delivery truck backed over my foot at work. My company attempted to settle with me quickly because they ...

  • Can a judgment foe a personal injury case be in my bankrupcty case if i was negligent or and careless?

    Sorry to burst any bubbles here, but the bankruptcy laws changed about one year ago and court judgments can no longer be discharged by declaring bankruptcy. Even if you declare bankruptcy, you mu...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster