Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Military Law

De facto admission of Geneva Conventions violations?


This is from a Washington Post article:

"The Bush administration has drafted amendments to a war crimes law that would eliminate the risk of prosecution for political appointees, CIA officers and former military personnel for humiliating or degrading war prisoners, according to U.S. officials and a copy of the amendments.

Officials say the amendments would alter a U.S. law passed in the mid-1990s that criminalized violations of the Geneva Conventions, a set of international treaties governing military conduct in wartime. The conventions generally bar the cruel, humiliating and degrading treatment of wartime prisoners without spelling out what all those terms mean."

The rest of the article is here: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14236728/

So whaddya think? It seems to me the thinking here is that if the administration can get the law changed, they can't be charged with crimes of which they know they are currently guilty of committing.

Article dateline is 8 Aug 2006.

We don't need de facto admissions. The Supreme Court has flat out said (a few weeks ago) that the Bush administration has violated Common Article 3 of the Geneva Convention.

And 18 USC 2441 (the statute passed in 1996 that you were referring to) makes violation of those provisions a war crime punishable as a federal criminal violation in the US.

But changing the law doesn't make past violations legal. It just allows the government to further violate the Geneva convention and other ratified international treaties (which have the same effect as federal law under Article VI of the Constitution) in the future without any penalties.

This is old news, the administration has been trying to dodge war crimes prosecution since the start of these wars.. :\

Monkey see monkey do,.,,Tony Blair see what ever Bush do,.., i feel these both animals look like humans
But they are found in field of Oil generating countries along with warfare,.,.,<*~*>,.,,

Tags
  Real Property Law   Professional Responsibility   Probate Law   Products Liability   Personal Injury Law   Native American Law   Military Law   Medical Malpractice   Mediation   Legal Malpractice   Legal Ethics   Landlord and Tenants
Related information
  • Are Instant Messenger conversations admissable in a court of law?

    Making them admissible is difficult. You would have to prove that he alone had access to the account. While a forensic computer analyst can track an IP address to a specific computer, it's h...

  • Deputy Sheffit?

    i retired as a deputy in 2001 with 25 years.danger is not something you can calculate. it is dangerous for both..one is a city employee and the other a county employee..thye salary is about the sam...

  • Isn't a drinking age unconstitutional?

    There is no constitutional right to drink, at any age. The government can regulate the drinking age.

    ...
  • Hiring Adm. Fallon was the GWB's only good move, but firing him for espousing peace is anti-Christian, right?

    Wow, I love it. Actually he was fired to telling truth to power. A legitimate administration would have been able to deal with his complaints honestly, they wouldn't have to fire a high ran...

  • Are these school officials educated beyond their intelligence?

    In my experience, I found that school officials and indeed teachers have very little intelligence, I once broached the subject of the rape of Nanking and a teacher asked "who's she"<...

  • Person I know; Born in Japan, but parents are US citizens. She elected to "stay" Japanese at age 18. McCain?

    Anyone born to US citizen parents is a US citizen regardless of the place of their birth. Anyone born on US sovereign territory is a citizen regardless of the citizenship of their parents. BTW, ...

  • Why do you support this proposed legislation that exclude others who are 18 years and not in service?

    I think the theory is that if they are willing to put their lives on the line, they should be treated as adults. It seems fair to me. They might die fighting and deserves something. All you have...

  • Should women be required to sign up for selective service?

    Yes, its our country too and the responsibility should be shared by all.

    ...
  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster