Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Intellectual Property

Sunglasses vs. Purses?


While at the mall the other day I saw a cart selling knock off designer sunglasses. They had the sunglasses laying out with signs saying compare to gucci, compare to prada, or what ever. Now if I was to take handbags and do the same thing, I would go to jail. Why can sunglasses be replicated and not purses? Are intellectual property laws not the same for all items? I just dont understand.

other than copyrights and trade marks, what about trade dress, it is certainly trade dress???

I THINK THEY ARE EQUALLY ILLEGAL



the people at the mall were just lucky not to get caught or were under different circumstances

+ they were stating to COMPARE TO DESIGNERS and not passing them off as the real designer's make


that would be the difference

<a href="http://www.guccicomte.co... Report It

I am willing to bet they looked similar, but didn't have the exact logos on them. Its illegal either way. Called copyright infringement.

Your missing the fact that most of the time purses are passed off as the real thing. Yes we know they are knock offs but they have the gucci label or prada label. As long as you don't misrepresent what it is you can sell it. Your thinking of trademark infringement

actually it's not copyright infringement...it's trademark infringement...copyright is for things that are written (e.g. books, plays, etc)

You can say "they compare to gucci" but you cannot say that "they ARE gucci". That is the subtle difference. You can compare a knockoff to the real thing, you just can't sell a knockoff AS the real thing.

Trade dress referrs to the general look of an object, like the shape of a Coke bottle (which is trademarked, so I know that's a bad example). Trade dress laws do not make it improper to suggest that a consumer compare one product with another. It would be a problem if they claimed the products were gucci or prada, etc., but if they are not misappropriating the trademarks, trade dress would probably be really hard to prove in such a case.

www.jffashion.com

the world of handbags

Tags
  Legal Malpractice   Legal Ethics   Landlord and Tenants   Labor Law   Juvenile Law   Investment Law   Intellectual Property   Insurance Law   Immigration Law   Health Care Law   General Civil Litigation   Family Law
Related information
  • China trade relations?

    It has to be proven first and when proven that the espionage case was done by the country and not a company, then that is the time a case can be built with regard to economic relations with China. ...

  • How many hours a week do lawyers work?

    As someone who just graduated from law school and who actually wrote an essay on this topic, I have a bit of perspective on this. However, while you should never use this as an answer on a law sch...

  • Why do I need to copyright my website?

    Copyrighting is automatic. Once you create it and publish it on your site, you automatically own the copyright. You do not need to post a notice or file for copy protection status. And the mail tri...

  • LAW QUESTIONS - serious lawyers?

    Serious lawyers generally recognize attempts to get others to do their essays. This is, after all, also the ethics section.

    ...
  • I started selling apparel with a certain word on it that was trademarked a week or two later by the MLB?

    If you can prove you were using it before they filed, you have a claim. Unfortunately, they'll probably be able to enforce their trademark, but you should get some compensatory damages due to ...

  • What are some examples of copyright infringement in relation to the use of Web resources?

    Any time a person copies (downloads) or distributes (uploads) a protected (copyrighted) work without permisison -- that's copyright infringement, Using someone else's intellectual prop...

  • How do I copyright lyrics and poems?

    They are automatically protected by copyright law whether or not you have an attorney or whether or not it is registered.

    ...
  • Is this legit or phishing?

    This is such a SCAM. Please don't send them any of your personal info!

    ...
  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster