Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Insurance Law

Why do we need title insurance when the constitution has the Contract Clause?


If you've bought a house, you are aware of being offered title insurance to protect your interest in the property should someone at a later date file a lien, dispute right-of-ways, easements, mineral rights, etc. I don't see how title insurance has a place. Retroactive claims are invalid after a sales contract has been agreed to by the seller and buyer. The Supreme court upheld this stating that Article I, Section 10, Clause I (the Contract Clause) of the Constitution states a contract of sale cannot be invalidated, even if illegally secured. Looking at the Yazoo land scandal and the U.S. Supreme Court case Fletcher v. Peck (which resulted in the rulling that the sales were binding contracts and could not be retroactively invalidated); how is title insurance is even needed? Granted, there may be small issues where the retroactive transfer of real property don't come into play but how big of an issue can this be? Are buyers not protected by the contract clause and precedence?

Look at it this way,

Better to be safe, than sorry.

Owning property with an imperfect title is possible but you do realize that nobody wants to buy something that may not be marketable because of the actions of prior tenants.

Besides that it is possible to enter into a purchase contract with someone who never had title. There is no way to enforce a contract that was invalid. Recovery against a schiester is next to impossible recovery from a insurance company is pretty easy to perfect if you have a valid claim.

The clause you cite has absolutely nothing to do with land transfers and adverse claims against title.

Tags
  Legal Ethics   Landlord and Tenants   Labor Law   Juvenile Law   Investment Law   Intellectual Property   Insurance Law   Immigration Law   Health Care Law   General Civil Litigation   Family Law   Estates Law
Related information
  • I have an insurance question... my company says it won't pay unless we sign a form ....?

    I sold insurance while I was in law school, and I never heard of what you are describing. The insurance company will ask you for your receipts for what you are claiming, which could include your c...

  • Renter with no insurance, faulty fire extinguisher?

    The landlord is responsible for anything that came with the house as part of the rental (appliances and safety equipment included). Health and safety issues are always the responsibility of the pr...

  • Insurance settlement? do we have a case?

    You should contact a personal injury attorney. The first consultation is free and see what they say.

    ...
  • Exemployer promised health insurance until 6-30-2006 but terminated insurance for 5-31-2006 what can i do now?

    With COBRA, you generally must make the premium payments yourself. If you have it in writing that the employer will cover you through 6/30/2006 then get a lawyer, if the amount is worth it. Cle...

  • Can your medical insurance company be sued for failing to pay a valid medical claim in full?

    You have several "hoops" to get through, but it sonds like you're on solid ground. Lets take each item as it comes up: You should read your policy. Some policies pay 100% of in ...

  • What is the penalty for driving without insurance on a motorbike, as i feel it was a genuine oversight?

    Often if you obtain insurance before the court date the judge will reduce the penalty (or eliminate it just making you pay the court costs). Getting a lawyer for minor traffic offenses usually isn&...

  • Insurance Claim - UK?

    Insurance claims work on a settlement being made, and then legal fees are added on top. So having the extra "fire power" won't change what he gets if he wins

    ...
  • Step daughter and insurance fraud!?

    Tell her how this act has changed your opinion of her in a negative way and how disappointed you are. Then leave it alone. Treat her accordingly and don't lend her your car or give her any oth...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster