Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Immigration Law

I need help with this... Please Help!!!?


The Arizona legislature passes a law allowing Mexican immigrants to enter the United
States freely and establish residency, directly contravening federal law. After the governor
signs the law, what would likely happen next?



the answer choices....


A. Courts in other states would use the law as precedent when deciding cases involving
Mexican immigration.
B. Federal district courts in Arizona would be obliged to decide cases based on the new
law.
C. The law would be invalidated based on the preemption doctrine.
D. The law would have to be upheld by the Supreme Court before it could be enforced.

This is any easy one. When examining any quesiton regarding conflicting legislation between two state actors do the following:
1) identify the parties (in this case the state legislature and the Congress of the U.S.)
2) identify where their power derives from (for the state legislature it would be from their police powers (which means the ability to legislate on matters of health, safety, welfare, and asthetics) versus the federal power of Congress to regulate and control the admission requirements for aliens which is a plenary power of congress that is set out expressly in the Constitution.
3) Consider the hierarchy of authority ( and in this case the federal Constitution trumps any individual states legislature under the Supremacy clause)

Therefore, the law should be considered invalid as offensive to the federal Constitution and should be adjudicated as such.

The power of Congress 鈥渢o exclude aliens from the United States and to prescribe the terms and conditions on which they come in鈥?is absolute, being an attribute of the United States as a sovereign nation. 鈥淭hat the government of the United States, through the action of the legislative department, can exclude aliens from its territory is a proposition which we do not think open to controversy. Jurisdiction over its own territory to that extent is an incident of every independent nation."

However, give greater specificity in exactly what the law in Arizona says would help me answer more specifically.

Tags
  Landlord and Tenants   Labor Law   Juvenile Law   Investment Law   Intellectual Property   Insurance Law   Immigration Law   Health Care Law   General Civil Litigation   Family Law   Estates Law   Environmental Law
Related information
  • If you needed a lawyer would you hire Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy?

    Of course they did. If they weren't helping them give jobs to immigrants while pretending to favor Americans (as the law appears to require), what were they being paid for in the first place?...

  • An amendment designed to ____ was approved by Congress but was not ratified by the states in the required 7yrs

    b) Equal rights shall not be denied on account of sex. Not passed between '71 and '82

    ...
  • To ensure every guy gets an affordable Hottest Chicks do you support Govt intervention ??

    Absolutely. I have a RIGHT to live in a society where every woman I look at will go to bed with me! You're the first person to have identified this serious social problem. All of the Demo...

  • What EU laws have been detrimental to England/UK?

    The law that allowed our country to be overrun by Eastern Europeans.

    ...
  • Channel 4 guns and knives season,what do you make of it?

    I saw some of it,I wouldn't watch that stupid scumbag Booth burn to death, never mind talk about something she is partly responsible for in her capacity as a barrister and wife of the ex PM th...

  • My daughter is in jail in Mexico for drug transport. She owns IRS money, is she exempt?

    With a drug conviction in Mexico, yes, her green card will be revoked, and she will never be allowed back into the US. You can advise the IRS of this if you want, but since she's not comin...

  • Breaking INS Laws?

    yes granted they accept jobs that americans can do... scrub your toilets, clip your hedges, mow your lawn, work at fast food places all for less than minimum wage. so yes i guess that being legal i...

  • Does any one know a good immigration lawyer in the l.a. area?

    Call the Los Angeles County Bar Association and ask for theiri referral service. They will give you information on at least 3 attorneys from which you can choose.

    ...
  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster