Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Education Law

Was the Brown vs Board of Education decision recently overturned?


The other day in my black experience class, a young lady stated that the Brown vs Board of Education decision had been overturned. She said it happened within the last month. I was just wondering if anybody else heard about this and if so can you explain it more for me. Thank You

No.

A few months ago the Court ruled in a couple of related cases concerning forced "busing" of students in Seattle, Wa and Louisville, KY.

In both cities, students are in general assigned to their closest school. However, every neighborhood has a different racial make-up, so that resulted in each school having different percentages of blacks and whites. So both school districts started programs of reasigning students to more distant schools, based solely on their race, so as to get the same racial mixture in every school.

The Supreme court ruled this was illegal. It is legal, they ruled, for schools to use race as a factor in determining placement, but NOT for them to base decisions SOLELY on race.

Some liberal pundits said that this "overturned" Brown as it would lead to white neighborhoods having white schools, and vice-versa. However, it really upheld Brown, working on the basis , as the court said, that "The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race."

Richard

No. But there was a case from Washington State recently...she could be referring to that.


Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1, 551 U.S. (2007), decided together with Meredith v. Jefferson, is a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that prohibited assigning students to public schools solely for the purpose of achieving racial integration and declined to recognize racial balancing as a compelling state interest.

"Brown vs. the Board of Education of Topeka" was a 1954 Supreme Court case that ruled "Seperate, but equal" was a violation of the 14th Amendment. This lead to the end of segregation.

If Brown vs Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas was overturned, that means schools can be racially segregated. Do you really think that will ever happen today?


The simple answer is No, it has not been overturn. That young lady didn't know what she was talking about.

No. It stands!

No, it has not been overturned. However, there have been a couple of recent cases where courts have ruled against racial integration schemes, so some people that don't know the details are claiming this.

Tags
  Family Law   Estates Law   Environmental Law   Entertainment Law   Employment Law   Elder Law   Education Law   DUI Law   Drunk Driving Law   Divorce Law   Discrimination Law   Disability
Related information
  • Arguments for paying for our education?

    Your position is that everyone should get the best education that they can afford, no more and no less? OK, well here are some strategies, but don't expect them to be pretty ones. One of...

  • LeGaL dRaMa PLEASE help my education's on the line /:?

    Fax them to your mom, get her to sign it, she sends it back, you're good to go, what's the problem?

    ...
  • Should we not have sex education?

    1.Sex education in schools are recommended to have knowledge. 2. Porno is playing on feelings and even with sex education no one can save you from your fall in that pit. 3.In your last line "...

  • Can people without a proper education or non graduates get into highly paid jobs and compete with graduates?

    Today I am 52 will be 53 36 days . I am retried .I have not work in 5 years .At 48 years I owned land my home, a very money making company, and I married my only wife jan. Life is good. I have a mo...

  • 1 in 4 teens have an std...abstanance only education?

    The real reason is PARENTS. The schools do teach what ever program the school board approves, whether it is abstinence only, safe sex, or both. But this really only gets into the mechanics of sex, ...

  • Should morality and virtue be at the forefront of Education throughout the world?

    Morality and virtue should be taught in the home. It is up to the parents to determine what morals and virtues they want to teach their children. The schools will have to teach social courtesy,...

  • Did the world forget about the salary income education of the generation born 1966-1976?

    Your SSI was stolen by your payee? That makes no sense hon. You'd be the payee. It can't be stolen by you. ...

  • Why don't We have the philosophy of"one nation one law and one education system"enshrined in the constitution

    Terrorism isn't about education or poverty. Bin Laden was very well educated and came from a very wealthy family. So did many of the other hijackers from 9/11. The Federal Government wanted t...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster