Mirror of Justice - All about Law and More
*Home>>>Civil Rights Law

Was the Miranda v Arizona Supreme Court case a criminal or a civil law case?


I understand that he was arrested for rape, but after he was tried and found guilty of the crime he was retried due to the fact that he did not know his rights. Going to the Supreme Court, his lawyers argued that there should be a way for him to have known his rights. Was this case a continuation of the criminal trial or was it a civil trial due to the fact that it was arguing his rights were violated?

This was not a separate civil trial, it was the appeal of the criminal conviction. It was a criminal case.

A girl was missing and the police decided Miranda had killed her. They picked him up and drove around with him in the car questioning him, till he said he wanted a lawyer. After he said that they continued to talk about how the family needed to know if she was dead, till he took them to where the body was.

He was taken to trial, and convicted of the murder. On appeal the issue was the violation of the right to an attorney. The appeal went to the US Supreme Court, along with some other cases, less well known, and we ended up with a judicial mandate for the police to inform people that they have certain rights, and a rule that the confession will not be admissible if the cops violate them.

A really really bad guy got a conviction overturned because the cops forgot there is a constitution.

I foresee similar instances as a result of the present administration's refusal to recognize our constitutional rights.

Criminal....
I am not sure of the particular crime...but he was asked if he wanted to make a statement, without his rights being fully explained, and without him acknowledging a full waiver of his rights.
He confessed...His confession was admitted in evidence. The USSC found that they trial court made reversible error in admitting the evidence, and ordered a retrial without the evidence.

Criminal.
And he was a slimy guy and came to a bad end.

You answered your own question. Since the case was based on the violation of his rights and had made it to the Supreme Court it would be a civil trial.

It was an appeal of the criminal court's verdict.

The case he was incarcerated for was a criminal case. When he sued the state saying his rights were violated, that case was civil.

It was a criminal case in which the police, to extract a confession, gave Miranda a dry run of his hanging. He even appeared in court and showed the rope burns to the judge, who was actually amused at the resourcefulness of the police. The argument, incidentally, was that the whole proceeding was tainted by torture. Of course, this was in the 1970s, when America was still a free country, one that was opposed to torture instead of using it as a matter of course.

Tags
  Collections Law   Consumer Law   Construction Law   Constitutional Law   Computer Law   Child Custody   Civil Rights Law   Business Law   Bankruptcy Law   Banking Law   Aviation Law   Appeals and Writs
Related information
  • Same-Sex Marriage, Civil Unions, Domestic Partnerships, and Defense of Marriage Acts?

    I think that gay marriage should be legal everywhere because gays and lesbians didnt ask to be homosexual, they were just born with it. And you CAN NOT dictate how other people live their lives cuz...

  • Caught shoplifting at Jewel not arrested just a civil demand. Do they have to tell my place of employement?

    Since you were not formally charged, they would have No reason to contact your place of employment. I do hope you learned a valuable lesson in all of this..

    ...
  • Did you hear about Joe Francis (Girls Gone Wild founder) getting arrested over a civil lawsuit, it's not right

    Its the same as if a man sleeps with an underage girl who claims to be 18, he is screwed. I guess his company should check these girls out better than just an ID. You know more proof of who they ...

  • How can an offense be a criminal and civil offense?

    It's the same in Texas. It is considered a civil offense. When you get a traffic ticket, you sign the "I promise to appear" portion of the ticket saying you acknowledge you got a...

  • Isn't it opposing on the rights of heterosexuals if you call same sex unions,,,marriage?

    As a gay man, I personally am only concerned that I have the same rights with my partner as a married couple, regardless of what it is called. However, I think if we go by your reasoning, it could ...

  • Rights for the accused protect all people. Comments anyone?

    I agree. The government has gotten too big and intrusive. They have manipulated many into thinking that questioning the government is "unamerican." Taking away the right of habeus ...

  • Is it right to get sued in a civil case after you've been found not guity in a criminal case?

    No one enters suit justly, no one goes to court honestly; they rely on empty pleas, they speak lies, they conceive mischief and bring forth iniquity. Therefore justice is far from us鈥udgment i...

  • My neighbors dog dose not stop barking do I have a wright with civil law to injoy my back yard?

    Here is a sample letter that you can send to the owner: [Your Name] [Your Street or Mailing Address] [Your City, State & Zip Code information] Via Certified Mail, Return Receipt Request...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster